04 August 2010

Wrong from illite"race"y

"Right to education" act mandates all schools, including those elite ones, should admit 25% of students from its locality without any test or filtering. I think this is a very good move by Government of India.

But the schools and highly literate rich parents are not welcoming this. No one is denying them the rich the right to education. But they want to remain elite and are afraid of the poor.



Their concerns are
1. Quality of education will suffer.
2. Rich students will learn foul language from poor students.

They should think for a moment, how they felt when their kid was denied admission by a school, which is considered to be slightly better than the one, where their child is currently studying! Not getting admission there will not affect their kid by much. But imagine the difference, it could mean to the poor kid.

Class system by birth still remains. Just that it has become modernized. The rich wants to makes sure that the poor cannot get quality education or get richer. The ancient class system was not as bad as, this mindset of these literates! Gandhiji would be proud of you, intelligent Indians. Untouchability is a sin.

All poor and illiterates are not bad in character or lack mental ability. Not all rich and educated have the best of character with highest mental ability. One's character or intelligence has nothing to do with his economical status.

I firmly believe that if this gets implemented correctly, many of the toppers will be from the 25%. I wonder what is the opinion of "Youth for equality" on this issue. IMO this 25% reservation is not a reservation. But the 100% only rich and educated is the 100% reservation. I love RTE.


Sankar said...


The day the western counterparts of these software engineers say, "India is a third world nation, we won't interact with them" and pull their jobs, I wonder what these "We are elite class" people will do.

rathinamurthy said...

Very happy about your change in views..

rathinamurthy said...

Read this..

Sankarlal's Thoughts said...

Very true.... As Rathinamurthy said your view is changed these days...!!

Nikanth Karthikesan said...

@Sankarlal Actually I told Rathinamurthy over-phone, that my views have changed. And he said here that he likes my changed ideas. And you say that to me. :)

My earlier reasoning were based on the premise that the world is completely fair, and rich & poor are rich & poor, because of their work. But I realised that my premise is wrong and hence some of my reasoning has changed.

BTW the law says neighbourhood = 3km radius. This might lead to rich arrogant people studying in boarding schools in the wild away from their parents... ;-) Anyway it would all settle if this gets implemented correctly.